Skip to content 
Metal roofing has gained significant popularity among Charleston homeowners due to its sleek, modern look, energy savings, and long-lasting durability. However, metal roofing systems come with specific challenges, especially in Charleston’s coastal environment. Issues such as roof leaks, metal roof corrosion, structural damage, and rain noise can make metal roofs less appealing compared to traditional roofing materials like asphalt shingles or clay tiles.
If you’re considering a new roof or roof replacement for your Charleston home, it’s crucial to understand these potential common metal roof problems. By learning about the cons of metal roofs, you can make a more informed decision about whether a metal roof system is the best choice for your needs.
Common Issues with Metal Roofs in Charleston, SC
Charleston’s coastal climate intensifies common metal roof problems due to the presence of saltwater air, high humidity, and frequent storms. For instance, metal roof corrosion and roof leaks are more likely here due to the exposure to salty air and heavy rainfall.
Additionally, improper installation details or poor roofing panels can lead to long-term issues. Extreme weather events, including hurricanes, increase the risk of structural damage or dent damage from hail and flying debris. For many Charleston homeowners, these challenges could make alternatives like asphalt shingles or clay tiles more appealing.
Problem #1: Higher Upfront Costs
A primary consideration for homeowners thinking about a new metal roof is the upfront cost. Metal roofing systems are typically more expensive to install than traditional roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles. While metal roofs can offer long-term savings due to their durability, they require a significantly higher initial investment.
However, metal roofing solutions can provide energy savings and a longer lifespan, making it a better long-term investment for some homeowners. If you plan on staying in your home for decades, a metal roof may be a good fit. But for those on a tighter budget, the cost can be a barrier.
Problem #2: Metal Can Dent
Another downside of metal roofs is their susceptibility to dent damage. While metal roofing is durable, it can be dented by falling tree branches, hail, or flying debris, especially if snow guards are not installed to manage snow buildup. Impact damage from hail is a particular concern in Charleston during hurricane season. If a metal roof panel gets dented, it can be challenging to restore its original look. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, are less prone to dent damage but can experience other issues like cracking or curling over time.
Problem #3: Challenging or Costly Repair
Repairing a metal roof can be more expensive and complicated than fixing a traditional asphalt roof. Since metal roofing panels are often custom-made, finding a matching panel for a roof replacement can be challenging.
Additionally, if installation errors occur or improper fasteners are used, repairs might require more labor-intensive methods, such as replacing entire sections of roofing panels. Repairing metal roofs might also require specialized tools or lifting devices to ensure the work is done safely. In comparison, asphalt shingles can be replaced individually without as much effort or cost.
Problem #4: Metal Roofs Can Rust
A significant concern for homeowners in Charleston is metal roof corrosion. The salty air and high humidity in coastal areas can accelerate the oxidation process, especially if the protective coating on the metal roof panels wears down. If the type of metal roof isn’t correctly suited for coastal environments, such as when galvanized steel is used, the roof may rust prematurely.
Proper protective coatings can slow this process, but they won’t prevent it entirely. Choosing a corrosion-resistant material like aluminum or copper can help, but these materials are more expensive. Regular cleaning and maintenance are essential to combat salt deposits and prevent rust from compromising the roof’s integrity.
Problem #5: Metal Expands or Contracts
Due to the temperature fluctuations in Charleston, thermal expansion and contraction can affect metal roofing systems. During the day, metal panels expand when they heat up, and at night, they contract as temperatures drop. This constant movement can cause fasteners to loosen or create gaps in the panels, leading to roof leaks. While standing seam metal roofs are designed to handle thermal expansion more effectively, improper installation of metal roofing panels or the use of rigid fasteners can exacerbate the problem. In contrast, asphalt shingles don’t experience the same degree of expansion and contraction because of their small size and flexible materials.
Problem #6: Appearance May Not Suit All Homes
While many homeowners appreciate the sleek, modern look of metal roofs, they may not be the best fit for every home, particularly in Charleston’s historic neighborhoods. The aesthetic of a metal roof system may clash with older, more traditional homes.
Additionally, the limited range of textures and finishes offered by metal roofing may not suit homeowners who prefer the look of traditional roofing materials like clay tiles or asphalt shingles. Oil canning, the visible rippling effect on flat form panels, is another issue that can detract from the appearance of the roof.
Problem #7: Oil Canning
Oil canning is a common issue with standing seam metal roofs. It refers to the visible distortion or waviness of the metal panels, which can be caused by thermal expansion or minor imperfections in the metal itself. While oil canning doesn’t affect the functionality of the roof, it can impact the roof’s appearance.
Some homeowners may not find the visual distortion appealing, especially if they were expecting a perfectly smooth surface. Asphalt shingles, by comparison, don’t have the same issue, as their layered structure hides any imperfections.
Problem #8: Requires Professional Installation
Installing a metal roof system requires specialized knowledge and skill. The installation details of metal roofing systems are more complex than those of traditional roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles. If the installation is done incorrectly, it can lead to roof leaks, misalignment, or inadequate flashing around vents, chimneys, and valleys. Given the intricacies involved, it’s essential to hire a roofing contractor who specializes in metal roofing to avoid costly mistakes. Even with the best materials, improper installation can result in long-term issues like water intrusion or structural damage.
Problem #9: Rain Noise
One of the most frequently cited drawbacks of metal roofing is the noise it generates during rainstorms. The sound of rain or hail hitting metal panels is much louder than on other roofing materials like asphalt shingles, especially during heavy rainfall.
In Charleston, where tropical storms and hurricanes are common, this can be a significant issue. Solutions such as soundproofing underlayment or insulation can help reduce this noise, but they add to the overall cost of the roof. Asphalt shingles, with their layered design, naturally dampen rain noise, making them a better choice for homeowners who prioritize a quiet interior.
Looking for Metal Roof Alternatives? Start Here:
Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles are one of the most widely used roofing materials across the U.S., and they’re especially popular in Charleston due to their affordability and ease of installation. They come in a wide range of colors and styles, offering great curb appeal. Many modern asphalt shingles are designed to resist high winds and moisture, making them a reliable choice in storm-prone areas.
Clay Tiles
Clay tiles offer a timeless, elegant appearance that complements many architectural styles, particularly Mediterranean and Spanish-style homes. Known for their long lifespan and durability, clay tiles perform exceptionally well in hot, humid climates and are fire-resistant by nature. Their thermal insulation properties also help reduce heat transfer into the home.
Concrete Tiles
Concrete tiles are similar in appearance to clay but are often more versatile in terms of design and profile options. They are extremely durable and can last for decades with minimal maintenance. Because of their weight and strength, they hold up well in Charleston’s unpredictable weather patterns.
Be Informed, Be Prepared: Your Roofing Decision Matters
While metal roofing offers significant benefits, such as durability, energy savings, and modern aesthetics, it comes with several challenges. Corrosion, thermal expansion, dent damage, oil canning, and the higher upfront cost are just some of the potential drawbacks to consider. Additionally, the need for professional installation, roof repairs, and the risk of uneven fading over time can add to the overall cost and maintenance requirements of a metal roof system.
For homeowners in Charleston, it might be worth exploring alternatives like asphalt shingles or clay tiles that are better suited for the region’s unique climate and offer fewer long-term problems. Consulting with a metal roofing contractor at Willow Ash Roofing can help you make an informed decision, ensuring your new roof provides reliable protection for many years to come.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are There Affordable Metal Roofing Options in Charleston, SC?
Metal roofing in Charleston, SC, is usually not as easy on the wallet as shingles. Even though there can be some cheaper choices, the price for the material and the hard work of installing it make it cost more. If you want a roof that saves you money on your home, you may want to look into other types of roofing materials.
What Are Some Good Roofing Materials For My Charleston Home?
Durable choices like asphalt shingles and clay tiles work well in the Charleston area. This is because the weather can be tough at times. A roofing contractor can help you pick materials that do not need much upkeep. They can also guide you to options that hold up well to storms and last for a long time. This be important when you want to make sure your home stays safe during any home improvement project.
Are Asphalt Shingles Better Than Metal Roofing?
Asphalt shingles are often a better choice than metal roofing for homes in Charleston. They cost less and give a steady, nice look. They also have fewer maintenance problems. With asphalt shingles, you do not have to worry much about dents or rust. On the other hand, metal roofing can cost more. It also comes with extra risks. If you want to know more, you can ask a contractor for a full list of pros and cons about metal roofing and asphalt shingles.
